Continue if you are looking for board games like Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective because that is what we are going to give you. Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective is a deduction game with as much intelligence and suspense as the ages-old entertainment property with the same name. You are in 19th century London presented with different cases to solve. It is also a Spiel des Jahres winner and one of the best board games based on books so you know it is good.
To determine this list we broke down Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective to what it is, a game of taking in many complex clues to determine a very thematic mystery. It has many different physical components that help immerse you in the theme. If you are looking for something similar, you have come to the right place. We took this into consideration and came up with this list of the 5 board games like Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective.
FOR MORE: Buy Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective on Amazon
#05 | Mythos Tales
Mythos Tales makes the list of games like Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective because it is another theme heavy tale from a time long ago about mystery and deduction. Like Sherlock, you need to use the clues at hand to navigate the masterfully well-written story.
It is Arkham 1920s, there will be many mysteries to uncover in this storytelling game of Lovecraftian terror. Using the provided newspaper, a list of allies, the directory of Arkham residents, and a map of Arkham, your job is to follow the clues from location to location, suspect to suspect, to unravel the mystery and answer the questions posed at the end of each scenario. For 1 – 10 players, games last about 2 hours.
FOR MORE: Buy Mythos Tales on Amazon
#04 | Witness
Witness makes the list of games like Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective because it is a story first murder mystery. There are all sorts of clues to be figured out, it is just a matter of if each character is going to pull their weight and bring what they need to the table. Like Sherlock and unlike the others on this list, this is a much older title, this is based on an existing property.
Witness is set in the world of Blake and Mortimer, a Belgian comic series started in the 1940s by writer/artist Edgar P. Jacobs. In the game, you each represent one of four characters and your goal is to solve mysteries or crimes by sharing information with one another — but with restrictions. Interesting hooks and character differences make for a fun and cooperative experience. For 4 players only, games run a quick 15 minutes each.
FOR MORE: Buy Witness on Amazon
#03 | Chronicles of Crime
Chronicles of Crime makes the list of games like Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective because it is another top of class crime-solving game You need to use heavy deduction and communication skills in order for your group to work together and solve the various crimes that fall in front of you.
The gameplay here is blended with an app that lets you reuse the board game components you get for multiple scenarios. Using the Scan&Play technology, each component (locations, characters, items, etc.) has a unique QR code, which, depending on the scenario selected, will activate and trigger different clues and stories. For 1 – 4 players, games last 60 – 90 minutes.
FOR MORE: Buy Chronicles of Crime on Amazon
#02 | Detective: A Modern Crime Board Game
Detective: A Modern Crime Board Game makes the list of games like Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective because you are immersed in a world of crime where everyone is a suspect and it is up to you to save the day. This is another great deduction game that requires you to take in clues and work together to solve the many well put together cases.
You will need to solve different cases and find out what connects them, you are going to use every resource you can, you are going to browse the game’s dedicated database simulating your agency’s resources, you will enter a city maze of old mysteries and crime, and you will cooperate with other agents or solve the mystery on your own. For 1 – 5 players, games run roughly 2 – 3 hours.
FOR MORE: Buy Detective: A Modern Crime Board Game on Amazon
#01 | Deception: Murder in Hong Kong
The top spot on the list of games like Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective rightfully goes to Deception: Murder in Hong Kong. This highly thematic murder mystery that is all about taking in the many clues along your path is very similar to Sherlock and a fantastic choice to try out if want something just as well written. Both are great games for any size group.
In the game, players take on the roles of investigators attempting to solve a murder case – but there’s a twist. The killer is one of the investigators! Your role and team are randomly assigned at the start of play and include the unique roles of Forensic Scientist, Witness, Investigator, Murderer, and Accomplice. While the Investigators attempt to deduce the truth, the murderer’s team must deceive and mislead. For 4 – 12 players, games run a quick 20 minutes.
