Smash Up Review

Smash Up Board Game Card Backs
Copyright © 2019 Matt Halvorson. All Rights Reserved.

Overall Score

5 Fun
8 Replayability
8 Player Interaction
6 Quality
5 Art & Style
6.4

Smash Up is the 2012 “shufflebuilding game of total awesomeness” for 2 – 4 players. It is a pure card game filled with all sorts of goofy “factions” (from aliens to pirates to samurai and more) that you need to “smash” together to build a deck that is going to let you attack communal bases better than your opponents. This is our review of Smash Up board game.

FOR MORE: Smash Up Page | How to Play Smash Up | Games Like Smash Up| Buy Smash Up


SMASH UP REVIEW by BOARD GAME HALV

– CATEGORY BREAKDOWN –

Fun (5 out of 10)

The game and your cards come and go very fast and you are very much at the whim of what you are dealt, so that is a bit limiting. That being said, the game is figuring out how to make two different groups work together and doing that is where the unique fun of Smash Up lands. It might be a little light in how deep it goes, but that is by design to keep things light, fluid and fast-paced. We will gladly take it the way it is because it is special.

Replayability (8 out of 10)

While the base game of Smash Up only comes with 8 factions, after close to ten years they are up to 74. You could play Smash Up for hours and always have a completely new team and a brand new strategy from the beginning. This game was built to be played over and over again and the foresight to see that from day one has made the execution of that nearly perfect. Well done. Even the thing you need to attack, the bases, completely changes every game.

Player Interaction (8 out of 10)

The highest marks of this Smash Up review are in player interaction. The game is all player interaction. It is not just the fact that you are fighting over bases against the other players, but most cards manipulate where and how your opponent’s people are going to be. The way you are going to win is by the very strategic stacking of people and effects on a base to sneak into the higher attack power to score those big points. When you see some of these things work together, the genius in it will blow you away.

Quality (6 out of 10)

When you have a pure card game, it makes things easier, no crazy pieces or odd-shaped box trays needed. That being said, they produced solid cards, and they come in solid, not too wasteful box. The game itself is pretty well made, in order to build a shell that can take in over 70 different factions like a well-oiled machine is something special. Though nothing feels that deep or specific, it gets the job done well as far as this Smash Up review is concerned.

Art & Style (5 out of 10)

The whole schtick of this game is that you are always going to have a crazy team like gnomes and dinosaurs or wizards and pirates. It is goofy and the base box sells it so well. It is almost out of a comic book but still in a tone that is as silly as the characters in it. The factions all have basic characteristics and the game creators do a good job of making each card fit in with the faction well. It is just all buttoned up exactly where it should be. For this review of Smash Up we are not saying the art & style is bad, just lackluster.

– IN CLOSING –

Smash Up Review

The world that Smash Up has created and built upon is something special. With the thousands of pairing options, there is so much gameplay and it is on top of a well-constructed machine. If you want a combat strategy card game, this is an incredibly wonderful (and popular) choice to make. This has been our Smash Up review of the popular 2012 board game.

Editor's Rating:
6.4

See the full explanation of the judging criteria here.

READ MORE REVIEWS HERE OR SEE WHAT OTHERS ARE SAYING BELOW.



SMASH UP REVIEW by OTHER REVIEWERS


9 / 10 – iSlayTheDragon Review
“Smash Up is a beautiful and highly thematic geek-fest layered on top of a very enjoyable card game. If the humor wears thin quickly, the mechanisms of each faction and the way the mechanisms of different factions collide lasts much longer. “

16 / 18 – Dice Hate Me Review
“Smash Up is smashing good fun, especially among gamers who can relax, revel in the sheer audacity of some stupid-good plays, and aren’t ashamed to let loose and let their geek flags fly.”

4 / 5 – The Board Game Family Review
“Smash Up scores high on our “Let’s play again” game meter. In addition to wanting to explore all the different combo abilities between factions, playing more frequently also speeds up the game play as players become more familiar with the cards.”

80 / 100 – Zatu Games Review
“Smash Up is a nerd-fest box of fun in a box. The seemingly endless amount of combinations that the expansions offer give the game some serious longevity and you don’t even have to collect them all if you don’t want to.”

5 / 6 – Play Board Games Review
“If you are sensitive about getting messed with than this game may not be for you. If however, you are looking for a game you can play with most anyone within minutes of sitting down at the table with them, Smash Up is for you.”

9 / 10 – Games of Board Review
“Smash Up is a simple game that has complex gameplay that brings together a range of different genres to battle for control of the world. After a few games you will find yourself pulled back to at least one faction, feeling like together you can win, and you can.”

Positive – Father Geek Review
“Smash Up is a game that tries to answer those questions geeks have debated for years. What would happen if you mix aliens and zombies? Wizards and robots? It’s a pop culture mashup…err…smashup.”


What would you put in your Smash Up Review? Let us know in the comments below or on our BGH Facebook Page.

Tags from the story
More from Board Game Halv

5 Games Like Gizmos

Continue on for board games like Gizmos and are curious about what...
Read More

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *